How to Develop Self-Awareness as a Leader
Self-awareness is the foundation of great leadership, yet many leaders operate on autopilot, unaware of how they truly show up.
This is Leadership Lessons, your blueprint for practical leadership success with actionable advice on how to excel as a manager, like how to craft your career narrative.
Leadership is, at its core, about influence. But before you can influence others effectively, you must first understand yourself. Self-awareness is the bedrock upon which great leadership is built. It allows you to recognize your strengths and weaknesses, understand how others perceive you, and adapt your approach to inspire and guide your team effectively. Without self-awareness, a leader can become blind to their own flaws, deaf to the needs of their team, and ultimately, ineffective in their role.
A lack of self-awareness in leadership is like driving a car with a fogged-up windshield. You think you see the road clearly, but in reality, you’re making assumptions based on limited visibility. Leaders who fail to cultivate self-awareness often fall into the trap of reinforcing their own biases, misinterpreting feedback, and making decisions that serve their egos rather than the team’s best interests.
A Lesson in Self-Awareness from the Fulfillment Center Floor
Years ago, I had an experience that drove this lesson home for me. It was fairly early in my career. I had just transferred to a new business and was responsible for a much larger team than I had previously led. I was eager to prove myself in this new role and set an ambitious goal for increasing our productivity metrics.
I believed I was approachable and open to feedback, yet I noticed that my team rarely voiced concerns or ideas in our meetings. To me, this indicated a lack of initiative on their part. Frustrated, I pushed harder—calling for more engagement, expecting more participation, and increasing my presence on the floor.
One day, my assistant manager, James, stayed behind after a meeting and hesitantly said, "Sir, most of us don’t feel comfortable speaking up because when we do, we feel shut down." That statement stunned me. I prided myself on being receptive, but James explained that my body language, tone, and quick rebuttals made people think their ideas weren’t valued. Instead of fostering dialogue, I had unknowingly created an atmosphere where employees feared speaking their minds.
That realization was humbling. I had been blind to how my leadership style impacted my team. I made a conscious effort to change—pausing before responding, actively encouraging differing viewpoints, and ensuring my nonverbal cues communicated openness rather than dismissal. Over time, I saw a transformation: more employees spoke up, engagement improved, and our efficiency targets became easier to meet because we were finally working as a collaborative team.
Self-awareness isn’t just about knowing your strengths—it’s about recognizing how your behaviors shape the environment around you. Leaders who lack this awareness can unknowingly create barriers that stifle their team’s growth.
Developing Self-Awareness: Three Key Strategies
Becoming more self-aware is not a one-time event—it’s a lifelong process. Here are three critical strategies I've used to develop self-awareness as a leader:
1. Actively Seek Honest Feedback
One of the biggest barriers to self-awareness is our own perception bias. We see ourselves through our intentions, but others see us through our actions. This gap between how we perceive ourselves and how others experience us can create blind spots that hinder our effectiveness as leaders.
To counteract this, actively seek honest feedback. (If you have one, a mentor can provide invaluable perspective on your blind spots). This means more than just an annual performance review—it requires cultivating a culture where your team feels safe providing real input. Ask specific questions: How do I respond under pressure? Do I listen well? Where do you see room for improvement in my leadership? Most importantly, when you receive feedback, resist the urge to defend yourself. Listen, reflect, and act on what you learn.
2. Practice Reflection and Mindfulness
In our fast-paced world, it’s easy to get stuck reacting rather than reflecting. But self-aware leaders take time to step back and assess their actions, decisions, and emotional responses.
One effective technique is to keep a leadership journal. At the end of each day, ask yourself:
What went well today?
What challenges did I face?
How did I handle them?
Did my actions align with my values and leadership principles?
How did my team respond to my leadership today?
Another related tool is mindfulness. Taking a few minutes each day to quiet the noise, focus on the present moment, and observe your own thoughts can help you gain clarity about your emotions and behaviors. Mindfulness enhances emotional intelligence, allowing you to regulate your reactions and approach challenges with greater composure.
3. Understand Your Team’s Identity and Your Role Within It
Leadership isn’t just about your personal growth—it’s also about how you fit into and shape your team’s collective identity. A self-aware leader understands that they are not an isolated figure; they are part of a larger system.
To lead effectively, ask yourself:
What are my team’s core values and beliefs?
How do my actions reinforce or contradict those values?
Am I positioning myself as an example of what we stand for?
One leader I greatly admired, Chris, had an impressive ability to make every employee feel like an integral part of the company’s mission. He understood that leadership wasn’t about standing above his team, but rather, standing with them. His self-awareness allowed him to embody the values of his team, and in doing so, he built trust, loyalty, and an unshakable sense of shared purpose.
Practical Tips for Applying Self-Awareness in Daily Leadership
Self-awareness isn’t just about introspection—it’s about applying that knowledge in real-world leadership situations. Here are a few ways to integrate self-awareness into your daily leadership practice:
Before making a major decision, ask yourself: Am I basing this on data, or am I letting personal biases influence my choice?
In conflict situations, pause and reflect: Am I listening to understand, or am I just preparing my response?
During team meetings, observe reactions: Do my words inspire engagement, or do I see signs of hesitation and disengagement?
When delivering feedback, consider the impact: Am I being constructive, or am I projecting my own frustrations onto my team?
Set aside 5-10 minutes a day to self-reflection or journaling.
Regularly ask your team for feedback on your leadership style. Show appreciation for honesty, and demonstrate visible changes based on feedback.
Final Thoughts
The greatest leaders are not those who never make mistakes—they're those who recognize their missteps, learn from them, and continuously strive to improve. Self-awareness is not a luxury; it is a necessity for anyone who aspires to lead with integrity, influence, and effectiveness.
As leaders, we are constantly shaping the reality of our teams. The better we understand ourselves, the better equipped we are to create a reality where trust, growth, and success thrive. Developing self-awareness requires effort, humility, and courage—but the rewards are immeasurable. It is the first and most important step in the lifelong journey of becoming a truly great leader.
Follow me on LinkedIn